← Journal

Science commentary · 2026-08-28 · Updated 2026-11-20

Mass gainers and heavy metals: why serving size changes exposure

Mass gainer servings can be 10× larger than a whey scoop. That changes the heavy-metal math.

Naked Nutrition Vegan Mass Gainer
Vega Premium Sport Protein (now Protein + Recovery)
Optimum Nutrition Serious Mass
MuscleTech 100% Mass Gainer
Featured: Naked Nutrition · Vega · Optimum Nutrition · MuscleTech

The short answer

Mass gainers can deliver more heavy metals simply because the serving is huge: 191–357 g in Consumer Reports' tests, against about 30 g for a whey scoop. CR found 7.7 µg of lead per serving in Naked Nutrition Vegan Mass Gainer and about 8.5 µg of inorganic arsenic in Optimum Nutrition Serious Mass, while MuscleTech 100% Mass Gainer had no detectable lead or cadmium [1]. Compare per-serving numbers, not per-gram ones.

Mass gainers are designed to deliver lots of calories, mostly from carbohydrates. Servings of 190–360 g are common — up to ten times a standard whey scoop. That has big implications for heavy metals.

Exposure scales with what you eat

A metal concentration that looks tiny per gram becomes meaningful when you eat 340 g of powder at once. That's why we always compare µg per labeled serving.

What CR found in gainers

  • Optimum Nutrition Serious Mass: 8.43 µg total arsenic per 340 g serving, almost entirely inorganic (8.47 µg inorganic — within measurement variation). CR flagged arsenic [2]. Do not confuse that gainer row with ON's lean Gold Standard whey (CR 0.27 µg lead on a 30.5 g scoop) — full brand fork in ON Gold Standard lead review [1].
  • MuscleMeds Carnivor Mass: 3.58 µg arsenic (2.41 inorganic), 1.21 µg lead [1].
  • Naked Vegan Mass Gainer: 7.7 µg lead — the highest in the set; CR advised against it [1].
  • Dymatize Super Mass: low lead (0.12 µg) but about 2 µg inorganic arsenic [1].
  • MuscleTech 100% Mass Gainer: lead and cadmium not detected; ~1.9 µg arsenic [1].
  • Transparent Labs Mass Gainer: 0.43 µg lead, ND cadmium, 0.52 µg arsenic — on CR's better-for-daily list [1].

All six gainers CR tested, per serving

Gainer (flavour tested)ServingLeadCadmiumTotal arsenicInorganic arsenic
MuscleTech 100% Mass Gainer, Vanilla Milkshake357 gnot detectednot detected1.86 µg1.99 µg
Dymatize Super Mass Gainer, Gourmet Vanilla333 g0.12 µgnot detected2.03 µg2.05 µg
Transparent Labs Mass Gainer, Sweet Vanilla194 g0.43 µgnot detected0.52 µgnot tested
Optimum Nutrition Serious Mass, Vanilla340 g0.61 µgnot detected8.43 µg8.47 µg
MuscleMeds Carnivor Mass, Chocolate Peanut Butter191 g1.21 µg1.67 µg3.58 µg2.41 µg
Naked Nutrition Vegan Mass Gainer, Vanilla315 g7.70 µg3.45 µg2.41 µg1.66 µg

Source: Consumer Reports' per-serving results [1]. CR only ran the inorganic arsenic test when total arsenic was above its level of concern [1].

Same concentration, very different dose

ON Serious Mass measured about 24.9 ppb (µg per kg) of inorganic arsenic [1]. Spread over a 340 g serving that is 8.47 µg; the same concentration in a 30 g scoop would be about 0.75 µg. Naked Nutrition Vegan Mass Gainer's lead works the same way: 24 ppb becomes 7.70 µg in a 315 g serving, but would be about 0.72 µg in 30 g [1]. That is why we always compare µg per labelled serving.

Why arsenic shows up

Rice and rice-derived carbohydrates such as maltodextrin from rice, or rice flour, can carry inorganic arsenic. FDA monitors inorganic arsenic in rice and rice products and points to the international Codex code of practice for reducing arsenic contamination in rice [3]. FDA also notes that current research indicates inorganic arsenic is more dangerous than organic arsenic, with more severe health effects from exposure [3]. Gainers built on large carbohydrate loads are more exposed to that route than lean protein powders.

Practical tips

  • Consider half servings, or building your own gainer from a low-lead whey plus whole foods like oats and bananas.
  • If you need a commercial gainer, choose one with low lead and low inorganic arsenic.
  • Don't assume "no lead detected" means clean — check arsenic too.

Filter gainers in the shop.

This is general information, not medical advice.

FAQ

Are mass gainers safe?

They are a large dose of powder, so any contamination is multiplied. In CR's tests, results ranged from no detectable lead (MuscleTech 100% Mass Gainer) to 7.7 µg of lead per serving (Naked Nutrition Vegan Mass Gainer) [1]. Pick one with low published lead and inorganic arsenic, or use a half serving.

Do mass gainers have heavy metals?

All six gainers CR tested had measurable arsenic, and five of the six had measurable lead, per serving [1]. Optimum Nutrition Serious Mass had the most inorganic arsenic at 8.47 µg per 340 g [1].

Is it better to make your own mass gainer?

It gives you control: a low-lead whey scoop plus whole foods like oats and bananas replaces a 191–357 g powder serving. Normal food carries some lead too, so see lead in food vs protein powder for the comparison.

References

  1. Consumer Reports. Protein powders and shakes — methodology and test results (Oct 2025, PDF)
  2. Consumer Reports. Protein powders and shakes contain high levels of lead (Oct 2025)
  3. FDA. Arsenic in Food

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate status never changes rank. 0 paid placements.

Spotted a data or stock issue?

Send the product link and what looks wrong. We check and log every correction.

Report an issue