← Journal

Science commentary · 2026-10-23 · Updated 2026-11-16

FDA's new cadmium limits for baby food: what they mean for protein powder (2026)

FDA has proposed its first cadmium action levels for baby food (10–45 ppb). They don't cover protein powder, but converting lab data to the same units shows why plant powders deserve caution, especially around children.

Huel Black Edition
Vega Premium Sport Protein (now Protein + Recovery)
Truvani Plant-Based Protein
Ritual Essential Protein Daily Shake
Featured: Huel · Vega · Truvani · Ritual

On 22 October 2026 the FDA announced draft guidance proposing action levels for cadmium in processed food intended for babies and young children [2]. The notice was published in the Federal Register on 23 October 2026 (docket FDA-2025-D-4023), and comments are open until 22 December 2026 [2]. It is part of the FDA's Closer to Zero programme and follows the final lead action levels for baby food issued in January 2025 [1][5].

This is general information, not medical advice.

The short answer

FDA proposed its first cadmium action levels for baby food on 22 October 2026, at 10–45 ppb depending on the food category [2]. They do not apply to protein powder for adults. Converting Consumer Reports' per-serving results to the same units shows the top plant powders near 100 ppb, while most whey and dairy powders are under 10 ppb or not detected [3][4]. That gap is why plant powders deserve caution, especially around children.

What the FDA proposed

The draft action levels cover packaged foods for children under two:

  • 10 ppb (parts per billion) for fruits, vegetables (except single-ingredient carrots) and mixtures, including grain- and meat-based mixtures [2]
  • 25 ppb for single-ingredient carrots [2]
  • 25 ppb for single-ingredient meats [2]
  • 20 ppb for yogurts, puddings and custards [2]
  • 45 ppb for dry infant cereals [2]

They do not apply to infant formula, beverages, raw agricultural commodities, homemade foods or snack foods, and they do not apply to protein powders or dietary supplements for adults. FDA action levels are non-binding, but they are concentrations at which the agency may consider a food adulterated. FDA cites kidney and bone effects from chronic cadmium exposure, and says young children may be more susceptible because of their smaller body size.

Converting protein powder lab results to ppb

Our rankings use micrograms (µg) per labelled serving, the unit Consumer Reports reported. Dividing by serving weight gives a concentration you can set beside the FDA numbers (1 µg per kg = 1 ppb). This is simple arithmetic on published Consumer Reports results [3][4], for context only. These limits were not written for protein powder.

  • Huel Black Edition Chocolate: 9.21 µg cadmium per 90 g serving — ≈102 ppb [3]
  • Vega Sport / Protein + Recovery Chocolate: 4.36 µg per 44 g serving — ≈99 ppb [3]
  • Truvani Plant-Based Chocolate: 3.27 µg per 33 g serving — ≈99 ppb [4]
  • Equip Prime Protein Chocolate (beef): 1.66 µg per 25.7 g serving — ≈65 ppb
  • Ritual Essential Protein Chocolate: 1.944 µg per 33 g serving — ≈59 ppb
  • Garden of Life Sport Plant Vanilla: 1.93 µg per 45 g serving — ≈43 ppb
  • PlantFusion Complete Creamy Vanilla Bean: 1.28 µg per 30 g serving — ≈43 ppb
  • KOS Organic Plant Protein Vanilla: 1.26 µg per 37 g serving — ≈34 ppb
  • Clean Simple Eats Chocolate Brownie Batter: 1.047 µg per 34 g serving — ≈31 ppb
  • Orgain Organic Protein Vanilla Bean: 1.03 µg per 46 g serving — ≈22 ppb
  • Premier Protein Powder Chocolate Milkshake: 0.649 µg per 41 g serving — ≈16 ppb
  • Naked Nutrition Vegan Mass Gainer Vanilla: 3.45 µg per 315 g serving — ≈11 ppb
  • MuscleMeds Carnivor Mass Choc PB: 1.67 µg per 191 g serving — ≈9 ppb
  • Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Whey Double Rich Chocolate: 0.24 µg per 30.5 g serving — ≈8 ppb [3]
  • Equate Whey Rich Chocolate: 0.217 µg per 30.4 g serving — ≈7 ppb [3]
  • BSN Syntha-6, Dymatize Super Mass, MuscleTech 100% Mass Gainer, ON Serious Mass, Transparent Labs Mass Gainer: cadmium not detected — ND

As a cross-check, Ritual's own published certificate for one Chocolate lot lists cadmium at 0.06 ppm, which is 60 ppb. That is in line with the ≈59 ppb from CR's numbers.

What the numbers tell you

  • Plant and chocolate-heavy powders run several times higher in cadmium. The top plant powders are around 100 ppb, roughly ten times the 10 ppb proposed for baby-food mixtures. Most whey and dairy powders are under 10 ppb or not detected.
  • Concentration and dose are different things. Naked Vegan Mass is only about 11 ppb, but its 315 g serving still delivers 3.45 µg cadmium. Most of a typical adult's 4.1 µg/day concern level (California Prop 65 MADL, used by Consumer Reports) goes in one shake. Our rankings use per-serving exposure for this reason.
  • Beef isn't automatically clean. Equip's beef isolate is about 65 ppb in this CR set. Its cadmium per serving is similar to several plant blends.

Practical takeaways

  • Don't use adult protein powder as a food for babies or toddlers. The new FDA levels show regulators are aiming for low tens of ppb in foods for under-twos. Many plant powders are far above that. See our pregnancy and kids guide.
  • If you're an adult who wants low cadmium, choose powders with ND or single-digit ppb. In the current CR data that means mostly whey and dairy proteins. Check the cadmium column in the full rankings.
  • If you prefer plant protein, compare µg per serving and keep servings modest. Prefer brands that publish lot-specific certificates. Read more in why plant proteins test higher and Prop 65 vs FDA reference levels.
  • This is a draft. FDA may change the numbers after the comment period, and it plans a webinar on 16 November 2026. Inorganic arsenic action levels for baby food are targeted for draft guidance in 2027.

Browse lab-tested picks with in-stock buy links in the shop.

Affiliate status never changes rank. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

References

  1. FDA. Closer to Zero: Reducing Childhood Exposure to Contaminants from Foods
  2. Federal Register 2026-21670 (91 FR 66796, 23 Oct 2026). Action Levels for Cadmium in Processed Food Intended for Babies and Young Children; Draft Guidance
  3. Consumer Reports. Protein powders and shakes contain high levels of lead (Oct 2025)
  4. Consumer Reports. Protein supplements test methodology and test results (Jan 2026, PDF)
  5. Federal Register. Action Levels for Lead in Processed Food Intended for Babies and Young Children; Guidance for Industry (Jan 2025)

Also referenced: Food Safety Magazine, 22 Oct 2026; Ritual Certificate of Traceability, Chocolate lot 521594405.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate status never changes rank. 0 paid placements.

Spotted a data or stock issue?

Send the product link and what looks wrong. We check and log every correction.

Report an issue