← Journal

Science commentary · 2026-10-02 · Updated 2026-11-19

Consumer Reports 2026 follow-up: five low-lead protein powders readers asked for

CR retested Clean Simple Eats, Equate, Premier Protein, Truvani and Ritual. Four landed under 0.5 ug lead per serving — here is what the numbers mean and how we added them to the rankings.

Clean Simple Eats Protein Powder
Premier Protein Protein Powder
Truvani Plant-Based Protein
Ritual Essential Protein Daily Shake
Featured: Clean Simple Eats · Premier Protein · Truvani · Ritual

The short answer

All five reader-requested chocolate protein powders that Consumer Reports tested in January 2026 had low lead. Clean Simple Eats measured 0.205 µg per serving, Equate 0.268 µg, Premier Protein 0.380 µg and Truvani 0.455 µg — all under CR's 0.5 µg/day level of concern. Ritual measured 0.525 µg, just over it, and CR said up to 6½ servings a week is fine [1][2].

When Consumer Reports published its 2025 protein powder investigation, readers immediately asked about the products that were not in the original set. In January 2026, CR answered with a follow-up: five reader-requested chocolate protein powders, tested with the same rigor as the original investigation.

The headline is genuinely good news. Four of the five products came in under CR's 0.5 µg/day lead level of concern — and the fifth only just missed it [1].

Why CR retested

The original 2025 investigation covered 23 products [3], but the protein aisle is much bigger than that. Readers wrote in asking about specific products they actually buy — including budget store brands and popular direct-to-consumer names. CR selected five of the most requested and put them through the same protocol.

The method, unchanged

CR used the same approach as the original investigation: ICP-MS testing to AOAC 2015.01, the standard method for heavy metals in food [2]. Lots were purchased in November 2025, results were averaged across 2–3 lots, and all figures are reported in micrograms per labeled serving [2]. Only chocolate flavors were tested. Full details are in CR's methodology and results PDF.

The lead numbers

Here is what CR found for lead, per labeled serving [2]:

  • Clean Simple Eats Protein Powder, Chocolate Brownie Batter — 0.205 µg
  • Equate Whey Protein Powder, Rich Chocolate — 0.268 µg
  • Premier Protein Protein Powder, Chocolate Milkshake — 0.380 µg
  • Truvani Plant-Based Protein, Chocolate — 0.455 µg
  • Ritual Essential Protein Daily Shake, Chocolate — 0.525 µg

Four of the five sit under the 0.5 µg/day level of concern CR borrows from California's Prop 65 MADL [4]. Clean Simple Eats is the standout at 0.205 µg — roughly 42% of the concern level — and CR listed it among options better for daily use, along with Equate, Premier Protein and Truvani.

Ritual came in at 0.525 µg, a hair over the benchmark. CR's practical guidance: up to about 6.5 servings per week stays within the concern level [1]. That is a limit-weekly verdict on our scale, not an avoid.

Cadmium and arsenic

The other metals were reassuring across the set. Cadmium ranged from 0.217 µg (Equate) to 3.27 µg (Truvani) — all below CR's 4.1 µg/day cadmium concern level, though Truvani's reading is worth noting if you drink it daily alongside other cadmium sources [2]. Total arsenic stayed low (0.17–0.48 µg), and inorganic arsenic was not tested separately because total arsenic was below CR's concern threshold [2]. Mercury was low or not detected throughout.

It is also worth stating plainly: there is no FDA heavy-metal recall associated with any of these five products. These are lab measurements against conservative benchmarks, not safety violations.

What this does to our rankings

All five products are now in our database with their exact CR figures, and they slot into the rankings by our usual rule: least lead first, then cadmium, arsenic and mercury, with protein completeness as the second axis. Clean Simple Eats and Equate land near the top of the chocolate category; Ritual sits mid-table with a weekly-limit note.

A few honest caveats. CR did not publish protein grams per serving for these five, so we list that field as not reported rather than guessing. The two plant products differ: Ritual is a single-source pea protein with added L-methionine, while Truvani's chocolate powder is a pea-led blend with pumpkin seed and chia seed protein. Neither has a published amino acid score, so we label their completeness as depending on the formula — the whey products are complete proteins by default.

The bigger picture

Combined with the original 2025 set, the pattern holds: dairy-based chocolate powders tend to test lower for lead than plant-based ones, but the gap is not absolute. Truvani's plant-based powder at 0.455 µg beat Ritual's and came in under the concern level — proof that a well-formulated plant product can compete.

As always, affiliate status never changes rank on this site. If you want to compare these five against everything else we track, start at the rankings or filter by category in the shop. Equate's store-brand context — why CR's 0.268 µg lead result still leaves a metals score of 0 without a brand COA — is unpacked in store-brand protein powder and lead. Source: Consumer Reports, January 2026.

References

  1. Consumer Reports. Readers asked us to test these 5 protein powders. All had low levels of lead (January 2026)
  2. Consumer Reports. Protein supplements test methodology and test results (January 2026, PDF)
  3. Consumer Reports. Protein powders and shakes contain high levels of lead (October 2025)
  4. OEHHA. Current Proposition 65 No Significant Risk Levels (NSRLs) and Maximum Allowable Dose Levels (MADLs)

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate status never changes rank. 0 paid placements.

Spotted a data or stock issue?

Send the product link and what looks wrong. We check and log every correction.

Report an issue