Use-case guide · 2026-09-10 · Updated 2026-11-03
How to read a Certificate of Analysis (COA) for heavy metals
Units, LOQ, ND, lot numbers and red flags — a practical guide to reading a protein powder COA.
More brands now publish certificates of analysis. That is good. But a COA is only useful if you can read it. Here is what to look for.
1. Check the lab and the date
A credible COA names an independent, accredited lab (often ISO/IEC 17025) and gives a test date. Results from three years ago tell you little about today's tub.
2. Match the lot number
COAs are batch-specific. Compare the lot number on the certificate with the one printed on your container. If the brand only shows one generic COA, treat it as a sample, not proof for your batch. Keeping that lot code also helps when you check recall notices or a best-by date — see protein powder shelf life and storage.
3. Understand the units
Labs often report metals in parts per million (ppm, mg/kg) or parts per billion (ppb, µg/kg). To get µg per serving:
- µg per serving = ppb × serving size in kg
- Example: 50 ppb lead × 0.030 kg = 1.5 µg per serving
If the COA reports ppm, multiply by 1,000 to get ppb first. The same mg/kg arithmetic is how UK/EU food-supplement ceilings (for example 3.0 mg/kg lead) turn into µg per scoop — worked example in UK/EU heavy metal limits for supplements.
4. Know ND and LOQ
- ND (not detected): below the lab's detection limit.
- <LOQ (below limit of quantification): detected or possibly present, but too low to measure reliably.
Neither means zero. They mean "below this threshold". Good COAs state what the threshold is. Labdoor's Legion Whey+ review, for example, reported all four metals below LOQ.
5. Look for the method
ICP-MS is the standard for trace metals. AOAC 2015.01 is the method Consumer Reports used. A COA that lists no method is harder to trust.
Red flags
- No lab name or accreditation.
- No lot number or date.
- Results reported only as "pass" without numbers.
- Limits set to permissive standards without stating which.
How we use COAs
We include brand COAs only when they are public, recent and quantitative, and we label them clearly as brand-reported. Lab methods are not perfectly interchangeable, so we show the proof type on every product card. See our methodology. Store brands without a published COA — even with a strong independent CR result — stay at metals score 0; Equate and other own-labels walks through that fork and what to ask customer service for. Microplastics are a separate contaminant class: a 2026 China sports-supplement study measured particles alongside metals, but we still do not score MP counts — see microplastics in protein powder: the 2026 study. A metals COA also does not prove the protein gram line is intact peptide-bonded protein — pair it with how to read a label for amino spiking. For how often brands must verify finished batches under dietary-supplement CGMPs — and how “fresh” a published COA needs to be relative to your lot — see COA freshness and lot testing. Marketing lines that only say “heavy metals tested” without µg/serving numbers are not enough for a metals score on this board.
Related articles
Protein powder without heavy metals: what “zero metals” actually means
2026-11-15
No lab can prove a scoop is metaphysically metal-free. ND and below-LOQ results still beat vague “clean” claims — here are the powders that publish the tightest brand panels against Prop 65 MADLs.
“Heavy metals tested” on protein powder: what the claim actually means
2026-11-13
“Heavy metals tested” on a tub or Amazon bullet is not the same as a lot-matched certificate of analysis with lead, cadmium, arsenic and mercury in µg per serving. Here is how to tell marketing from usable lab maths.
Does protein powder expire? Shelf life, storage and lot numbers
2026-11-07
Best-by dates are mostly about quality, not a federal safety cut-off. How humidity and heat affect opened tubs, spoilage signs, why metals do not change in storage, and why lot numbers matter for COAs and recalls.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate status never changes rank. 0 paid placements.